How to defend Catholicism without going insane
Based on the framework used by Catholic Voices, a communication strategy designed to help Catholics discuss controversial topics with clarity and composure, avoiding defensive or aggressive reactions.
I attended a (virtual) talk way back in the midst of all the flood control concerns. The speaker was Jack Valero, who at that time was a Press Officer for Opus Dei in Britain. He co-founded Catholic Voices, a communication project established in 2010 that trains lay Catholics to discuss controversial topics effectively.
Here are my notes about his talk and how they would be useful in modern-day apologetics in matters of the faith.
Catholic Voices framework
1. Recognize the frame
Where is the person coming from? Was the statement from personal experience? Was the statement from tradition, a passed down well-structured information that just made sense?
2. Find the shared value or common ground
When Non-Catholics ask for references it's often resorts to Verses vs Verses. Scripture (excluding the Deuterocanonical1 books) is something Catholics have in common with Protestants. Therefore, being knowledgable in Scripture creates that bridge in communicating.
There is also the concern of morals. Morality is already implanted to each and every human being in the guise of rationale. Only humans are able to rationalize concepts and systems. Christians believe that it’s God who has implanted himself in the form of the conscience, which can be sharpened through Scripture and means of spiritual formation.
Let the other person that you sincerely and actually want the same things: equal rights, respecting everyone’s dignity, the right to be heard and seen, etc.
3. Shape the messages from common knowledge or experience
Often the Church already has an answer to general arguments. As opposed to “I think…” statements by non-Catholics, it’s up to the apologist to let the message get through.
Key ingredients to make 1-3 work:
- Clarity with Charity. The aim is to have both. Clarity alone can hurt. Charity can keep you silent. The choice of words are what makes the message go through.
- Attentive listening as a discpline. Listening requires humility. Being defensive is a manifest of a fragile ego.
- Reframe. Do not retort. There’s no use making a remark when the goal is to shed light. You wouldn’t want to have heated arguments.
- Don’t make it a goal to win. Shed light. We apologists only have the marketing means, God handles the sale (conversion). Have a “Through me, not by me” mindset.
How to practice the framework
Take any content (easy) or conversation (difficult, as it requires realtime responses) and break them down to Points 1-3:
- What’s the frame?
- What Catholic values am I showing to this person in my response?
- What’s the message of the Church in response to such issue (with clarity and charity)?
Books from the Bible that were removed by major Protestant religions: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach (Ecclesiasticus), Baruch (including the Letter of Jeremiah), 1 Maccabees, and 2 Maccabees↩